Competitor board
Seven apps, fresh installs recorded by Martin on 13-14 Nov 2026 (Czech App Store, so prices are in CZK). Screens and flows from the recordings; market numbers (US ratings per month, share of 1-3 star reviews and top complaint) from the 12 Nov App Store research. Personal details in screenshots are blurred.
The market at a glance
iOS app-blocker and screen-time market, App Store US + GB, pulled 12 Nov 2026. Public data only: keyword rankings, ratings, charts and the most recent written reviews. Apps tested below are in blue.
Search: who owns the category words
Top-10 appearances in 28 keyword lists (14 keywords x US/GB)
Growth: who is gaining fastest
New US ratings a month since launch, a proxy for installs
Money: who earns
Position in the Productivity top-grossing chart (1 = top). Unrot, one sec, ScreenZen and Focus Friend are not in the top 100.
| App | US | GB |
|---|---|---|
| SocialLite | 45 | 31 |
| Opal | 52 | 32 |
| BePresent | 42 | 34 |
Sentiment: how loved each app is
Share of recent written reviews with 1-3 stars (lower is better)
Pain: what users complain about
Top theme in each app's 1-3 star reviews, and how many mention the Screen Time permission. Paywall dominates the fast growers, bugs dominate the incumbents.
| App | Top complaint | Mention the permission |
|---|---|---|
| Opal | Bugs / not blocking 36% | 0.9% |
| Unrot | Paywall / price 70% | 0.0% |
| one sec | Paywall / price 40% | 0.8% |
| Brick | Bugs / not blocking 38% | 2.3% |
| BePresent | Paywall / price 67% | 1.1% |
| SocialLite | Paywall / price 51% | 0.0% |
| ScreenZen | Bugs / not blocking 43% | 5.4% |
| Focus Friend | Paywall / price 42% | 2.5% |
So what for Lull
1. Free blocking, paid extras after the first held block, is a real position against the hard-paywall leaders: they earn, and they are resented for it.
2. The two fastest growers won with a positive loop (Unrot: earn your time) and a smaller ask (SocialLite: only Reels and Shorts). Both fit Lull's activation problem.
3. Reviews cannot show the permission leak. Only first-run testing of the apps could, which is what this board does.
Why these seven
One per strategy, not the seven biggest. Scores 1-5 are a judgement from the evidence above.
| # | App | Strategy | Traction | Leak relevance | Beyond blocking | Why test it |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Opal | Category leader | 5/5 | 4/5 | 3/5 | The bar the panel compares Lull to |
| 2 | BePresent | Gamification + social | 5/5 | 4/5 | 5/5 | Top grosser; streaks, leaderboard, rewards |
| 3 | Unrot | Earn your screen time | 4/5 | 3/5 | 5/5 | Fastest 2025 grower; positive loop |
| 4 | SocialLite | Narrow scope (Reels/Shorts only) | 4/5 | 5/5 | 3/5 | 2026 breakout; smaller ask |
| 5 | one sec | Friction, not hard blocks | 4/5 | 4/5 | 3/5 | Pause before open; heavy setup |
| 6 | ScreenZen | Free, donation-funded | 4/5 | 4/5 | 2/5 | Free-model contrast; best reviews |
| 7 | Focus Friend | Gentle gamification (pet) | 3/5 | 2/5 | 5/5 | Reward loop without the hate |
All 28 keyword lists, top 10 (OpenASO)
| Keyword | US top 10 | GB top 10 |
|---|---|---|
| app blocker | 1Opal2ScreenZen3Refocus4AppBlock5Brick6one sec7BePresent8BlockSite9OpenAppLock10App Blocker | 1ScreenZen2AppBlock3Opal4Refocus5Brick6one sec7AppLock8BlockSite9BePresent10App Blocker |
| screen time | 1Opal2ScreenZen3BePresent4Unrot5ClearSpace6one sec7Screen Time Tracker8Refocus96710Unglue | 1ScreenZen2Opal3Unrot4675one sec6BePresent7Flora8ClearSpace9Screen Time Tracker10Unglue |
| focus | 1Firefox Focus2BPS Focus3Focus4Focus Friend5Forest6Opal7Focos8Focustown9OneClay Focus10Focus Traveller | 1Firefox Focus2Flora3Focos4Focus Friend5Focus Self Service6Forest7Focus Traveller8FocusFlight9Exocus10FocusVille |
| dopamine detox | 1Rewire2one sec3Dopamine Detox4Dopamine Detox5Dumb Phone (dp)6Dopamine Detox7Dopamine Detox8Quiet Wall9Dopamine Detox10NoMusic | 1Dopamine Detox2Dopamine Detox3one sec4Rewire5Dopamine Detox6Dopamine Detox7Lighthouse8Dopamine Detox9Rebirth10Habitopia |
| social media blocker | 1Opal2ScreenZen3SocialLite-Block Reels&Shorts4Refocus5BePresent6Flora7one sec8Barrier9Social Media Blocker10AppBlock | 1Opal2ScreenZen3SocialLite-Block Reels&Shorts4one sec5Refocus6Barrier7Social Media Blocker8Block Reels Shorts9Friends6710block the feed |
| block apps | 1Refocus2Opal3ScreenZen4Brick5BlockSite6AppBlock7one sec8App Lock9ScreenLocation10AppLock | 1Refocus2Brick3ScreenZen4Opal5BlockSite6AppBlock7Stop Brain Rot8FeedOff9BlockerPro10Pause |
| phone addiction | 1Opal2BePresent3Dumb Phone (dp)4ScreenZen5Beave6ClearSpace7Interlude8TapJail9Phone Addiction10SPACE | 1BePresent2Opal3one sec4ScreenZen5Dumb Phone (dp)6Interlude7ClearSpace8Beave9TapJail10SPACE |
| digital detox | 1Detox2Digital Detox App Blocker3Opal4Digital Detox ADHD AppBlocker5one sec6Unscrolly7Unplug8StayAway9Pause Digital Detox10Cohesive | 1Digital Detox ADHD AppBlocker2Detox3Digital Detox App Blocker4one sec5Opal6Digital Detox7Cobweb8Pocket Focus9BrainSober10Digital Detox App |
| focus timer | 1Focus Keeper2Focus timer3Focus Friend4Forest5Focus Traveller6Cat On Chair7Focus To-Do8FocusPomo9Pomodoro Focus Timer10FocusFlight | 1Focus Keeper2Focus Friend3Focus timer4Flora5Focus Traveller6Focal7Forest8FocusFlight9FocusPomo10Study Bunny |
| screen time control | 1Opal2ScreenZen3Unrot4BePresent5ClearSpace6Refocus7Jolt8one sec9Brainrot10Unglue | 1ScreenZen2Opal3Unrot4one sec5Flora6Refocus7Unglue8BePresent9Screen Time Control10Brainrot |
| stop doomscrolling | 1one sec2SocialLite-Block Reels&Shorts3BePresent4No Scroll5Focus Plant:forest app blocker6Stop Doomscrolling7Lock Screen 278Screencat9Stop Doomscrolling10Rewired | 1one sec2SocialLite-Block Reels&Shorts3Doomblock4Pause5Undoom6Stop Doomscrolling7Lock Screen 278Screencat9Stop Doomscrolling10No Scroll |
| quit social media | 1Days Since2StopSocial3Anti-Scroll4Doomscroll5Lately6QuitBook7Habit Tracker8Blank9Amara Social10Æon Social | 1StopSocial2Anti-Scroll3Doomscroll4Days Since5Friendly Social Browser6Naze7Lately8Pouch Quit9Sked Social10No PMO |
| focus app | 1Focus Friend2Forest3Opal4Flora5Exocus6Cat On Chair7Focus Traveller8FocusPomo9Study Bunny10FocusFlight | 1Flora2Focus Friend3Forest4Focus Traveller5Study Bunny6Exocus7Focus Wander8Opal9Offline10Cat On Chair |
| habit tracker | 1Habit Tracker2Finch3Habit Tracker4Routine Planner5Onrise6Habit Tracker7Productive8Atoms9Grit10Structured | 1Habit Tracker2Habit Tracker3Onrise4Dots5Atoms6Structured7Routine Planner & Daily Habits8Finch9Habit Rabbit10Productive |
OpenASO, US + GB App Store (iPhone search), 12 Nov 2026. Ranks are a proxy for search visibility, not installs.
Sources: OpenASO keyword rankings, US + GB App Store, 12 Nov 2026; iTunes Search API; Apple RSS top-grossing (Productivity) and customer reviews (most recent, up to 1,000 per app, US + GB; themes tagged by keyword). Ranks, ratings and chart positions are proxies for visibility, installs and revenue, not the real numbers.
Side by side
What each app promises, who it is for, when it asks for Screen Time and money, what happens after "no", and what brings people back.
| App | USP | Audience (inferred) | Screens before Screen Time ask | Monetisation | After a "no" | First real block | Retention loop | US ratings / month | 1-3 star reviews (top complaint) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpalPremium, calm, gem collectibles | Get years of your life back: premium rules and blocks you can't talk yourself out of | Working adults, knowledge workers | 12 | Soft paywall after permission 1 990 CZK / yr, 7-day trial |
Not shown | Not reached | Gem milestones, notifications, streaks | 1,286 since 2020 | 68.3% Bugs / not blocking (36%) |
| BePresentGamified, social, Noom-style quiz | Psychology + gamification: blocking with streaks, XP, leagues and accountability partners | Gen Z / students who feel addicted | 14 | Paywall after permission (no X seen) 1 490 CZK / yr, 7-day trial |
Re-asks in a loop, no skip | Not reached | Streaks, XP, leagues, friends get a text | 1,450 since 2022 | 18.0% Paywall / price (67%) |
| UnrotGamified mascot, guilt-to-hope, high pressure | Your apps go to jail; earn screen time back with Brain Coins from healthy habits | Teens and young adults, meme tone | 29 | Paywall BEFORE permission + countdown + exit offer 1 290 CZK / yr (exit: 3-day trial, 699) |
Re-asks in place with a reason | ~6 min (app locked) | Coins, habits, quests, streak | 3,298 since 2025 | 45.7% Paywall / price (70%) |
| SocialLiteCalm, shock stats, authority quotes | Same apps, no algorithm: Lite versions of social apps without Reels/Shorts | Young adults who keep social apps for DMs; parents | none | Hard paywall after account wall 799 CZK / yr or 249 / mo, no trial |
No Screen Time ask | Not reached | Hours-back goal, commitment | 1,902 since 2026 | 12.5% Paywall / price (51%) |
| one secScience, calm | Science-backed pause: a breathing exercise before a distracting app opens | Self-aware students and knowledge workers | 15 | Skippable paywall BEFORE setup 349 CZK / yr, 7-day trial |
Dead end: system error, no re-ask | Not reached (Shortcuts setup abandoned) | Prevented / time saved counters | 324 since 2020 | 31.0% Paywall / price (40%) |
| ScreenZenCalm, dark, minimal | The only free app blocker: mindful pause + a budget of opens per app | Price-sensitive students, young professionals | 8 | Skippable tip screen (donation) Free; tips 129-499 CZK |
Re-asks in place + help link | ~2 min: 'open your app now' | Opens-left budget, streak, earn time | 841 since 2021 | 7.4% Bugs / not blocking (43%) |
| Focus FriendCosy pet game | A cute bean knits while your phone is down; focus earns socks to decorate its room | Students, Gen Z, creator fandom | none | Soft offer later; upsells at friction points 499 CZK / yr, 999 lifetime |
No Screen Time ask (blocking opt-in) | ~2 min (focus timer, no block) | Socks currency, room, pet feelings | 655 since 2025 | 5.9% Paywall / price (42%) |
When do they ask for Screen Time, and when for money?
Screen number in onboarding. Blue = Screen Time ask, red = first price shown. Lull for comparison.
Positioning
Placement is my judgement from the recordings, not measured.
simple blocker + visible wins
Who they target
Inferred from their questions, tone, imagery and attribution options.
| Audience | Apps | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Gen Z who feel addicted | Unrot, BePresent, Focus Friend | Meme tone, slang chips, age buckets from "Under 18", TikTok / Shorts as source, mascots, streaks, leagues |
| Working adults who want focus | Opal, one sec | Job-type questions (Technology, Founder, Remote), 9-5 rules, science and peer-reviewed proof, premium calm design |
| People who keep social apps for friends | SocialLite, ScreenZen Minimal | "Why not just delete social media?", keep DMs and streaks, remove Reels and the feed; parents as a second buyer |
| Price-sensitive students | ScreenZen | "The only FREE app blocker", tips not subscriptions, High school / College options |
Lull's users (data): 33% less social media, 33% focus at work, 22% better sleep, 12% family; most say 3-7 hours a day; 48% US, 16% UK. Lull sits between "working adults" and "keep social apps but cut the feed".
How they're built (from the app builds)
Static read of the shipped iOS builds (frameworks, extensions, bundled text), 14 Nov 2026. Notes per app in research/teardown-2026-11-14/.
| Opal 4.23 | BePresent 0.18.113 | Unrot 4.1.3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Remote paywalls | Superwall + RevenueCat | Superwall + RevenueCat | Superwall |
| Experiments | Amplitude Experiment + Firebase A/B | none visible beyond Superwall | Firebase Remote Config + A/B: whole onboarding v3 / v5_long / v5_campaign |
| Analytics | Amplitude + session replay | Mixpanel + session replay, Segment | Firebase / GA4 |
| Lifecycle messaging | Bundled notifications: day-1, day-6, weekly report, streak, unblock budget | Customer.io (push + in-app campaigns), reward ladder day 3/7/10/14 | Challenge system; milestone pushes planned |
| Block screen | Custom shield + unblock budget, emergency passes | Goal-tailored shield, streak on shield, "open the app to collect XP" | Custom shield (copy not readable) |
| Anti-churn | `permissionDetection` + `trackingWatchdog` background jobs; Screen Time passcode lock | "DON'T delete BePresent while your apps are blocked"; detects other blocker apps | - |
| Paid acquisition | Adjust, Facebook, Google Ads, 50 SKAdNetwork ids | Singular, Facebook, Google Ads | AppsFlyer, Appstack, Facebook, Google Ads |
Verdict: all three serve paywalls remotely; Unrot switches whole onboarding flows by remote config and judges them on purchases; the first week is engineered (reports, reward ladders, streak pushes); the leaders watch for silent loss (Opal's permission and tracking watchdogs, BePresent's "don't delete" warning).
App by app
Method: builds pulled with Apple Configurator from Martin's own iPhone on 14 Nov 2026 and read statically only (framework list, extension types, Info.plist, bundled text and config files). The encrypted app binaries were not decrypted, run or copied, and no keys, ad unit ids or tokens were copied. Not provable this way: how often each app tests, or which variants won.
The category default
- Paywalls served from a server and A/B tested (Superwall, RevenueCat); the paywall module in the app holds only two strings.
- Experiments with Amplitude Experiment and Firebase A/B; Amplitude analytics with session replay.
- Onboarding as 221 strings in modules (chat, commitment, lifetime projection, distraction picker, permission alert). The drawn Screen Time dialog is real code.
- A programmed first week: day-1 and day-6 reports, weekly report, rotating streak messages, an unblock budget, emergency passes.
- Background jobs named permissionDetection and trackingWatchdog: it notices a revoked permission or broken tracking.
For Lull: Lull needs the same heartbeat: today a user who deleted the app or revoked Screen Time still looks protected in the data.
The top grosser of the seven
- Superwall and RevenueCat; Mixpanel with session replay and Segment; no dedicated experiment tool visible.
- Customer.io runs push and in-app campaigns, so the first weeks change without app releases.
- Onboarding is 459 of 1,492 copy keys, a third of all copy.
- The block screen is the engine: goal-written buttons ("Study Mode On", "Kids Over Apps"), the streak on the block screen, a route into the app to collect XP.
- Anti-churn: "don't delete while your apps are blocked", detects other blocker apps, a reward ladder on days 3, 7, 10 and 14.
For Lull: Lull took the goal-written block screen and a programmed first week, not XP and leagues: they pull attention into the app.
The fastest grower
- Remote config assigns new installs to one of three whole onboarding flows, a third each, with the old flow as control and fallback.
- The flow variant is passed to the paywall tool, so onboarding and paywall are tested together.
- Judged on purchases and trial starts; onboarding completed is secondary. An earlier onboarding test was stopped first: a series, not one test.
- The opening chat ships as data; a newer version has 3 steps instead of 8.
For Lull: A small team can test whole onboardings fast if the flow is configurable. Lull should judge the same test on Screen Time granted and a first held block, not purchases.
Chosen for its single path
- The path is a journey through 25 numbered landscape stages, from a desert to a sunset.
- A shareable image per stage and a teacher who congratulates you.
- Habit help without games: 3, 10 and 30-day challenges, add to calendar, invite a friend. Two tabs only.
- The same machine underneath: Amplitude Experiment, Firebase Remote Config, Customer.io with an in-app inbox, RevenueCat.
- 61% of 315 recent US and GB reviews mention the single path, the structure or the simplicity.
For Lull: This is where Lull's Path came from: one visible route (Notice, Protect, Extend, Own it), one step a day, milestones instead of points.
Patterns that shaped the prototype
1. Everything important is remote and tested. The prototype has the same switches: Path vs today, soft vs hard Screen Time ask, block screen A/B.
2. The first week is engineered. Lull: one step a day, day-2 and day-3 nudges written for the goal, a held-block card instead of XP.
3. The leaders watch for silent loss. Lull: a heartbeat event is the first engineering task in the year plan.
4. They optimise for purchase; Lull optimises for protection. Same kind of onboarding test, judged on a held block within 24 hours.
Patterns across the seven
Quiz, then a loss projection ("13 / 18 years of your life", "45 days a year", "12 years"), then a gain, then a commitment ritual: hold-to-commit (BePresent, SocialLite), fist bump (Opal), "Commit to my goal" (ScreenZen). Lull has the loss ("days a year") but no gain and no commitment.
Opal, BePresent and ScreenZen draw a copy of the iOS dialog with an arrow at Continue plus a privacy line ("never leaves your device"). Unrot explains it in one line.
ScreenZen, Unrot and BePresent re-ask on the same screen (ScreenZen adds a help link). one sec ends in a system error, the same dead end Lull has (3% of deniers ever grant).
All 7 show a price before the user's first block or session: before permission (Unrot, one sec, SocialLite, ScreenZen tip), right after it (Opal, BePresent) or after a tutorial (Focus Friend). Nobody waits for a first block. Annual plans by default, priced per day or week, with a trial-end reminder (Opal, BePresent) or an exit offer (Unrot).
Only ScreenZen hands off: "Leave ScreenZen and open your selected app now" (~2 min). In 6 of 7 recordings the tester never hit a real block screen. Lull's activation metric (first held block) is exactly the step competitors neglect.
Pauses (one sec, ScreenZen), budgets of opens, timed unblocks, Lite apps without the feed (SocialLite, ScreenZen Minimal). Hard blocking is sold as a Pro upgrade (Opal and SocialLite Hard Mode).
Coins (Unrot), socks (Focus Friend), gems (Opal), XP and leagues (BePresent), opens budget (ScreenZen). Earning screen time back is a trend (Unrot, ScreenZen Practice). Only BePresent puts a streak on the block screen; nobody makes the held block itself the reward.
Feature map: what fits Lull, and when
Every competitor feature checked against one test: does it help the user hold the next block or keep protection on, in under a minute, without pulling attention into Lull? Verdicts are judgement from the recordings, builds, reviews and Lull's data. Source: research/feature-map.md.
| # | Feature | Who has it | Lull problem it hits | Verdict | When |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Day 1: getting the first win | |||||
| 1 | Personal stake: goal, loss + gain projection | Opal, BePresent, Unrot, SocialLite, one sec | 25% leave before the ask | Yes, but cut the work, not the stake (~4 screens) | Now |
| 2 | Commitment ritual (hold-to-commit) | BePresent, SocialLite, Opal, ScreenZen | 29% refuse the ask | Yes, as the permission button, not an extra screen | Now |
| 3 | Coached Screen Time ask (drawn dialog + arrow + privacy line) | Opal, BePresent, ScreenZen | 29% refuse | Yes (note App Review risk on imitating system UI) | Now |
| 4 | Re-ask in place after "no" | ScreenZen, Unrot, BePresent | 3% of deniers ever grant | Yes | Now |
| 5 | Rules proposed from your answers | Opal ("Works for 97% of users like you"), ScreenZen, BePresent presets | Picking apps loses 8% | Yes: path picks apps + schedule by goal | Now |
| 6 | "Open your app now" first-block handoff | ScreenZen | Activation; weekend installs | Yes, but a prompted block doesn't count as activation; weekend = "locked in for Monday" | Now |
| Week 1: making the habit | |||||
| 7 | One guided path, one step a day | The Way | Silent by day 3 (27% of activated) | Yes: the frame for the whole app | Now |
| 8 | Goal-tailored block screen copy | BePresent ("Study Mode On", "Kids Over Apps") | Block screen is a dead end | Yes | Now |
| 9 | Held block shown as the win | BePresent (XP, paid), Opal (gems) | No reward today | Yes, free and simple: "You held it. +1 on your path" | Now |
| 10 | "Instead" replacement at the block (stretch, water, text someone) | ScreenZen Practice, Unrot habits | 19% take a break | Yes, short list per goal | Now |
| 11 | Day-1 / day-6 / weekly reports | Opal, BePresent | Silent by day 3 | Yes: "time won back" | Now (day-1), Q2 (weekly) |
| 12 | 3 / 10 / 30-day challenges | The Way, Unrot | Fade from day 7 (44%) to day 21 (15%) | Yes, as path milestones | Now (3-day), Q2 |
| 13 | Softer off switch ("pause for today") | none seen; Opal unblock budget is closest | 20% switch all groups off by day 14 | Yes: Lull's own idea | Now |
| 14 | Streaks + streak freeze | BePresent, Opal, ScreenZen | Habit | Light: path days count, a missed day doesn't reset the path | Q2 |
| 15 | Home-screen widget (today's step, wins) | all | Reason to come back without opening | Yes | Q2 |
| Blocking that bends instead of breaking | |||||
| 16 | Opens budget per app per day | ScreenZen, BePresent intentions | Social users fade (41% week 2) | Yes, as the "social" path option | Q3 |
| 17 | Pause before open (breathing) | one sec, ScreenZen | Breaks, all-or-nothing | Test as an option, not default (reviewers: low DAU impact) | Q3 |
| 18 | Emergency passes / unblock budget | Opal | Locked-out anger (worst reviews) | Yes, small budget | Q2 |
| 19 | Earn screen time with healthy habits | Unrot (fastest grower), ScreenZen Practice | Social segment | Test once on the social path | Q3 |
| 20 | Hard / strict mode | Opal (Pro), SocialLite | Strict holds 100%, used in 7% | Keep, free; offer in week 3 "extend" | Q2 |
| 21 | Lite apps (feed removed) | SocialLite, ScreenZen Minimal | Social segment | No for now: needs own app versions, heavy for a small team | No |
| Social | |||||
| 22 | One accountability friend (told when you break a goal) | BePresent | Habit, fade | Yes, light, opt-in | Q4 |
| 23 | Friend challenges ("do the path together") | The Way, BePresent groups | Habit, organic growth | Yes | Q4 |
| 24 | Global leagues / leaderboards / XP | BePresent | - | No: competition and XP pull attention into the app; wrong for a calm "has your back" brand | No |
| 25 | Referral / gifting | Opal (20 friends = PRO), The Way (gift) | Growth | Yes, with monetisation | Q3-Q4 |
| 26 | Family / parents mode | SocialLite, BePresent, Opal | New buyer | Later: different product | No (year 1) |
| Games and content | |||||
| 27 | Pet or character that reacts | Focus Friend, Unrot, Opal gem | - | No as a character; the path's visual (a place you move through) carries progress | No |
| 28 | Soft currency from a focus timer | Focus Friend (socks), Unrot (coins) | - | No: rewards timer time, not held blocks; invites gaming; Forest/Focus Friend own it | No |
| 29 | Content library (sounds, stories, meditations) | Opal | - | No: costly, pulls attention in | No |
| The machine underneath | |||||
| 30 | Remote-config onboarding + experiments | Unrot (v3 / v5 A/B/C), Opal, The Way | Every idea tested vs today | Yes: variant switch in the prototype | Now |
| 31 | Heartbeat + permission watchdog | Opal (`permissionDetection`, `trackingWatchdog`) | Silent loss invisible | Yes: first engineering task | Q1 |
| 32 | Lifecycle messaging tool (CRM) | BePresent, The Way (Customer.io) | Week-1 programme without releases | Yes | Q1 |
| 33 | Anti-deletion nudge | BePresent ("DON'T delete while blocked"), Opal passcode lock | Silent loss | Yes, gentle | Q2 |
| 34 | Session replay analytics | Opal, BePresent | Understand onboarding drop-off | Yes | Q1 |
| 35 | Remote paywall (Superwall) + subscriptions (RevenueCat) | Opal, BePresent, Unrot | Monetisation (parked) | When unparked: paywall after the first held block | Q3 |
The year
- Q1 - Day 1 works. Path onboarding vs today (A/B on grant rate, then activation), heartbeat + session replay + CRM in place. Target: activation 33% -> 40%+.
- Q2 - Week 1 sticks. Block-screen win, "instead" cards, 3/10-day milestones, weekly report, softer off switch, widget, emergency passes, gentle anti-deletion. Target: fewer silent by day 3, fewer switched off by day 14; week-2 protected as guardrail.
- Q3 - Paths that bend. Social path with opens budget and an earn-time test; strict mode in week 3; monetisation unparked (paywall after the first held block, referral). Target: social week-2 protected 41% -> 50%.
- Q4 - Together. One accountability friend, friend challenges, referral loops. Target: organic share of installs.
Not in year 1, and why: global leagues/XP (attention, wrong audience), pets and currencies (crowded, reward the wrong thing), content library (cost, attention), Lite apps (engineering), family mode (another product).
Where Lull can be different
1. Value before money. All seven show a price before the first block or session. Lull keeps blocking free and charges after the first held block.
2. Own the first block. Only ScreenZen hands you off to feel a block in the first minutes. That is Lull's activation metric, and it is the step everyone skips.
3. Never a dead end after "no". Copy ScreenZen's coached ask and in-place re-ask.
4. Make the held block the reward. Others reward timers, coins or collections. Only BePresent rewards the held block (XP collected via its block screen, for paying users). Lull can own the free, simple version.
Opal
Get years of your life back: premium rules and blocks you can't talk yourself out of












Patterns to steal or avoid
- Steal: make the Screen Time ask the payoff of a personal story. Opal spends ~12 screens building stakes (goal, persona, own screen-time guess, '18 years' loss vs '5 years' gain) so the permission feels like the obvious next step.
- Steal: pre-ask screen that shows a mock of the iOS dialog with an arrow at the right button and a privacy line ('stays 100% on your phone').
- Steal: proposed default rule based on answers ('rules I propose for you', 'You can edit this later') so setup is one tap, not a blank picker.
- Steal: trial-end reminder picker and 'No payment due today' to defuse trial fear before showing price; consider per-day price anchoring.
- Avoid: overreach and bugs that dent trust - 'You lost your streak' on day 1, 'NaN' under trial reminder options, an 'Analyzing your activity 57:50 left' wait on the home screen.
- Watch: Opal's pull-back on day 2 is notifications (unblock ended, nudges) and collectible gems, not the home screen; Lull needs a reason to open the app that is not just the shield.
Not seen in the recording
- Anything before the 'Closer...' gem screen (recording starts mid-intro; App Store, splash and first screen not captured)
- Deny path for Screen Time or notifications
- The block / shield screen itself and the unblock flow
- Contents of 'Other plans' and any monthly price
- Whether a downsell or second paywall appears after closing the paywall (only a brief flash of the 'Get 2+ hours back' screen at ~218s, likely the dismiss animation)
BePresent
Psychology + gamification: blocking with streaks, XP, leagues and accountability partners














Patterns to steal or avoid
- Steal: a Screen Time primer that shows a replica of the system alert with an arrow "Tap Continue" - it removes uncertainty about which button to press. Pair it with a one-line privacy promise.
- Steal: a quiz that builds the stakes before the ask (goal, daily hours, "13 years of your life" -> "6.5 years back"), so the permission and paywall land when motivation peaks.
- Steal with care: the commitment ritual ("I, <name>, will..." + hold-to-commit) followed by "You made your promise. Here's ours: 7 days free" plus a reminder-date picker - a strong trust-building lead-in to the paywall.
- Avoid: an account wall before any value (Apple sign-in failure cost this user about 1.5 min and a restart) and an ATT prompt on screen 2 - both are friction before the user knows what the app does.
- Avoid or soften: an immediate auto re-ask loop on Screen Time deny with no exit; a calmer app should offer 'not now' and explain what will not work without it.
- Consider: the first real block happens only after paywall and setup - Lull could show one real block on a chosen app before asking for money.
Not seen in the recording
- What the user tapped on the ATT prompt
- The exact taps during the Screen Time re-ask loop (deny is inferred)
- Whether the paywall can be dismissed or skipped (no close button seen; user started the trial)
- A real block / shield screen triggered by opening a blocked app
- Accountability partner or group flow beyond the Social tab landing
Unrot
Your apps go to jail; earn screen time back with Brain Coins from healthy habits














Patterns to steal or avoid
- Earn-to-unlock turns blocking from punishment into a trade; a visible price per minute (1 coin = 1 min) makes the cost of scrolling concrete without a hard wall
- Personalised cost framing works fast: '3 hours a day -> 90 hours a month -> 45 days a year' plus a dot-grid of a year
- Show the mechanic before asking: a 3-step demo ('Your apps go to jail', earn, spend) primes the Screen Time ask long before it appears
- Deny recovery in place: keep the pre-ask screen, add one line of why it is required, and re-request on the same button
- Friction-by-design at unlock (card tap, receipt 'the algorithm doesn't love you back', refund for ending early) adds reflection while staying playful; make it toggleable like Unrot does
- Watch-out: 29 screens and a paywall before any blocking value is high-risk for a calm brand; Lull could test permission + first block before the paywall
Not seen in the recording
- The actual Shield / block screen when opening a jailed app
- Photo-verification of a habit in practice (only in the demo)
- Whether either paywall can be dismissed to use the app free
- Day-2 behaviour, reminders or streak notifications
- Any friends/social or accountability features
one sec
Science-backed pause: a breathing exercise before a distracting app opens












Patterns to steal or avoid
- Lead with an outcome stat backed by named research ('saves 2 hours every day: that's 1 month per year', Max-Planck DOI) on screen 1; proof is the brand.
- Use a short self-assessment to recommend a mode ('Based on your answers, we think...'), then show the paywall right after this personalised payoff, before asking for any permission.
- Keep the paywall skippable with a real free tier, and anchor annual price as a monthly figure with a 1-week trial; add Family/Student options for reach.
- Show the intervention itself as a 'Try It' demo inside the paywall, so users feel the pause before committing.
- Avoid one sec's weak spots: the Shortcuts setup is a 6-step, video-assisted chore the tester abandoned, and the Screen Time denial ends in a generic system-style error with no recovery path. A pre-permission explainer plus a friendly deny screen with a Settings path is an easy win.
- Make the home screen empty state do the work: a single tooltip 'Add apps to one sec' pointing at Add, with Prevented / Time saved counters ready to fill.
Not seen in the recording
- Any app screens before the welcome stat (recording starts on it)
- Notification permission ask
- A live intervention or block on a real app (only in tutorial video)
- Completed Shortcuts automation
- Account creation / sign-in (only 'or sign in to sync subscription' link)
ScreenZen
The only free app blocker: mindful pause + a budget of opens per app












Patterns to steal or avoid
- Pre-ask with a drawn replica of the Screen Time dialog plus an arrow at Continue, and on denial stay on the same screen with changed copy and a help link, then re-ask - zero dead ends.
- Turn personalisation into the plan: 5 short per-app questions (what you want, time that feels right, how much friction, why not delete, when it hurts) feed a pre-ticked "Finally, commit to your goal" summary with a single "Commit to my goal" CTA.
- Make the block a pause, not a wall: "Why am I checking?" + visible opens-left budget + a 5 s countdown on Open, with time-boxed 5-minute unlocks and a Relock chip.
- Hand off immediately after setup: "Leave ScreenZen and open your selected app now!" gets the first block experienced inside ~2 minutes of install.
- Offer a softer alternative to blocking (Minimal app versions that hide Reels/Explore) for users who answered "Parts of it are genuinely useful".
- A soft, skippable support ask early can coexist with a free core; keep it clearly skippable so it does not tax permission completion.
Not seen in the recording
- Notification permission outcome (user's tap not legible)
- Account creation / sign-in for ScreenZen itself
- Any subscription or free trial
- Halo price
- Friends / social features in use
Focus Friend
A cute bean knits while your phone is down; focus earns socks to decorate its room












Patterns to steal or avoid
- Frame the problem through a character's stakes, not the user's guilt: "whenever you pick up your phone, I drop my stitches" makes putting the phone down an act of helping someone.
- Get to a first session fast and without permission friction: first focus started at ~119 s with zero OS permissions; strict blocking (Deep Focus) is an opt-in upgrade later. Lull could let users run a first soft session before the Screen Time ask, then ask with proof of value.
- Soft quit with emotional friction: a 10 s free-cancel grace, then an 'Are you sure? ... they'll be really sad' confirm, then a kind 'It's OK! We tried!' - discourages quitting without shaming.
- Seed the paywall in the narrative before showing a price, then place priced offers at natural friction points (out of currency, locked toggle) rather than a hard wall.
- Close the loop after a session with a break-timer prompt, turning a stop into a Pomodoro-style rhythm.
- Visible progress that accrues (empty room that fills up) gives a reason to return on day 2; Lull's blocks could feed a similar accumulating artefact.
Not seen in the recording
- Screen Time / Family Controls permission prompt and its deny handling
- System notification permission prompt (only a settings button)
- Deep Focus Mode actually blocking an app / any shield screen
- A completed session and the socks reward
- Stats screen, locked room, gift box contents
Sources behind the in-app notes
The prototype shows one sourced note a day on the 4-week path, a "Why it works" line on each daily step and rotating "Did you know" tips. These are the 12 studies behind them, each checked against the study or its official write-up on 15 Nov 2026, with the caveat where the evidence is weaker than the headline.
| Week | Note, as shown in the app | Source | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Notice | About 43% of what we do each day is habit, done while our mind is elsewhere | Wood, Quinn and Kashy, J. Personality and Social Psychology 83(6), 2002 | Some summaries give 41%, depending on the definition |
| 1 Notice | Nearly half of US teens say they are online almost constantly, up from 24% a decade ago | Pew Research Center, Teens, Social Media and Technology 2024 (n = 1,391, ages 13-17) | Teens, not adults |
| 1 Notice | Screen focus switches every 47 seconds on average | Gloria Mark, UC Irvine; book Attention Span, 2023 | Logging studies of information workers, not a clinical attention test |
| 2 Protect | A phone on the desk, even face down and off, lowered test scores | Ward, Duke, Gneezy and Bos, J. Assoc. Consumer Research 2(2), 2017 (~800 people) | Single study; replications mixed, not checked here |
| 2 Protect | A short pause before opening an app cut openings by 57% over 6 weeks | Grüning, Riedel and Lorenz-Spreen, PNAS 120(8), 2023 (n = 280) | Study of the one sec app; first author is its lead scientist |
| 2 Protect | Urges rise and fall like a wave; riding one out works | Bowen and Marlatt, Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 2009 (college smokers) | Urges were not weaker; smoking was lower. The popular "37%" figure is from secondary sources, not used |
| 3 Extend | If-then plans help more than intentions alone (94 studies) | Gollwitzer and Sheeran, Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 38, 2006 (d = 0.65) | A 2024 meta-analysis finds smaller bias-corrected effects; we say "help", not a number |
| 3 Extend | Capping social apps at 10 min each a day for 3 weeks reduced loneliness and depression | Hunt, Marx, Lipson and Young, J. Social and Clinical Psychology 37(10), 2018 (n = 143 students) | Students, 3 apps, iPhone only. Supports the social path's 30 min/day plan |
| 3 Extend | A lit screen before bed delayed sleep and next-morning alertness vs a paper book | Chang, Aeschbach, Duffy and Czeisler, PNAS 112(4), 2015 | Lab setting, 4 h of reading; critique by Zeitzer in PNAS 2015 |
| 4 Own it | A new habit took a median 66 days to feel automatic; missing a day did not undo it | Lally, van Jaarsveld, Potts and Wardle, Eur. J. Social Psychology 40(6), 2010 | Median of modelled estimates; range 18-254 days |
| 4 Own it | Leaving Facebook for 4 weeks gave small wellbeing gains and lower use afterwards | Allcott, Braghieri, Eichmeyer and Gentzkow, American Economic Review 110(3), 2020 | Effects small; US sample before 2018 midterms |
| 4 Own it | Parents reporting more phone interruptions with kids also reported more child behaviour problems | McDaniel and Radesky, Child Development 89(1), 2018 (170 families) | Correlational: a link, not a cause (stated on the note) |
Left out on purpose: phone-checks-per-day survey numbers (methods unclear), "years of your life" projections (not checkable), and anything that calls phone use an addiction as a diagnosis.
Where to go next
The board is the research. These show what came out of it and where every number comes from.
Scripts 01-06 in the analysis folder reproduce every number. Raw competitor recordings are not shared.
SocialLite
Same apps, no algorithm: Lite versions of social apps without Reels/Shorts
Patterns to steal or avoid
Not seen in the recording